Kyle from The Trend Report just put into words something I’ve been ruminating on for a long while. The internet is experiencing an epidemic. An epidemic of explainers.
These aren’t just any old “explainers.” Let me paint the picture for you:
A creator sits on camera, maybe in front of a green screen with obnoxious neon lights, maybe they’re in their minimalist office, sipping a latte. They’re dissecting something, a recent pop-culture moment or a micro aesthetic shift. An indie horror film or the proliferation of Japanese culture in the USA.
They use high-brow vocabulary and media theory, and they spend ten minutes unpacking a three-second clip.
On the surface, it looks like a renaissance of internet intellect.
But if you watch enough of them, a strange, hollow sensation starts to set in. You realise that most of these creators don’t actually have a distinct point of view, real-world qualifications, or an original thesis to offer. They are just explaining what already happened, adding layers of pretentious padding to a trending topic purely to capture a sliver of the attention economy.
They’re not a professional yapper, but a Professional Viewer.
It marks a fascinating behavioural evolution. In the 2010s, early internet clout was generated through the humble “reaction video”, literal footage of someone screaming, gasping, or laughing at a piece of media in real-time. In the mid-2020s, the format has had an aspirational upgrade. We no longer just react to content; we “thinkpiece” it.
The Aspirational Upgrade of the Reaction Video
The shift from the simple 2010s reaction clip to the modern analytical video essay reveals a deep shift in how we manufacture social capital online. A decade ago, being an internet consumer was a passive, unglamorous state of being. You watched the video, you shared it, and you moved on.
Today, because the digital landscape is entirely oversaturated with media, simply consuming content feels common. It carries no social distinction.
By taking a trending topic and wrapping it in an ‘elaborate’ cultural analysis, these creators are attempting a cognitive magic trick, trying to prove that they are no longer “just a viewer” sitting passively on a sofa. No they are better than that, than you, the average passive scroller. So they position themselves as an elite interpreter of the feed, someone who has superior vision and can decide what the average brain (you! average dummy!) misses.
And it’s a classic distinction of the modern internet mindset: “I’m not like the rest of the audience. I see the hidden matrix underneath the static, and that makes me culturally superior.”
Pleasing the Digital Panopticon
This obsession with performing intellectual superiority only thrives because we live inside a fully realised digital panopticon. If you are unaware of the theory, you’re welcome. You too can now theorise about the digital prison in which we are held.
Anyway, we are all acutely, painfully aware that the comment section, the algorithms, and our peers are constantly perceiving and judging every second of our digital lives.
In a world where traditional structural institutions like legacy academic systems or professional journalism have lost their gatekeeping authority, anyone can claim the title of a cultural expert. Speak with a little more confidence than the next guy, and anyone will believe you are.
Thus, the analytical think piece video has become the default tool for signalling intellectual value to both the machine and our peers. I can put money on the fact that many of these creators don’t make these videos simply because they have a deep, burning passion for dissecting the hidden semiotics of a reality TV star’s outfit choice, but because the algo rewards anyone who can transform a low-stakes pop-culture flashpoint into a high-fidelity semantic event.
It’s a performative dance designed to win validation from the crowd and algorithm-driven visibility from the platform.
The irony, of course, is that by turning everything into an overanalysed cultural crisis, we hollow out the actual value of real criticism. When everyone is an elite viewer explaining everything all at once without any institutional guardrails, the public square simply dissolves into a loud, exhausting echo chamber of synthetic insights. We are drowning in interpretations of reality, while losing our grip on reality itself.
The YAP Takeaway
This explosion of performative cultural analysis is a clear symptom of media saturation. When everyone has access to the same tools of mass distribution, simply sharing a trending clip is no longer enough to win the attention game. Creators have to launder their consumption through a lens of academic pretension just to stand out in the feed.
It’s not necessarily good or bad. It just is. And it’s interesting.
Do you want to please the panopticon? The choice is yours.


